FR
  • A2
  • Asking well
  • Choose
  • 5 min

Compare two answers

Situation

The situation

Same request, two models: judge with your own criteria.

You work at the front desk of a driving school in Rennes. You need to tell students about a new rule: a lesson cancelled less than 48 hours ahead is still charged. You want to compare two models before choosing.

Idea 1 of 3

Each model writes its own way

Each AI model was trained differently. Given the same request, two models give two different answers: more or less accurate, more or less clear.

Idea 2 of 3

The aidock Duel

In the Duel, two models answer the same request side by side. In blind mode, their names stay hidden until you vote: you judge the answer, not the brand.

Idea 3 of 3

Your criteria before reading

Decide before reading what matters: accuracy (are the facts respected?), clarity, tone, length. Otherwise, the longest answer often looks like the best.

Example

Before and after

Avoid

I’ll keep the one that looks the most professional.

Better

I’ll keep the one that states the 48-hour rule correctly, that students understand in one reading and that stays polite.

Why? Criteria set in advance stop you choosing on looks. Accuracy comes first.

Question 1 of 3

Two models get the same request. What happens?

Two models get the same request. What happens?
See the answer

They give different answers, to be compared Each model learned differently: its answers vary in accuracy and style.

Question 2 of 3

In a blind duel, when do you find out the models’ names?

In a blind duel, when do you find out the models’ names?
See the answer

After you vote The names appear after the vote: you judge the answer first, without being swayed by the brand.

Question 3 of 3

Why set your criteria before reading?

Why set your criteria before reading?
See the answer

So you do not pick the longest one by reflex A long, polished answer impresses. Your criteria bring you back to what matters.

Exercise

Your turn

Write the request you will send to both models, then fill in your 3 criteria to judge their answers.

Ctrl + Enter to check your request.

Checklist

  • Write the request: a message to students, to do
  • Give the rule: 48 hours, to do
  • Fill in the 3 criteria, to do
  • One criterion checks the facts, to do

End of the lesson

Lesson complete

Key point

To compare two answers, set your criteria before reading them, accuracy first.

Next lesson: Small and large modelsTry it in a DuelContinue in the chatBack to the path